What the tests found about naming the reason
The UK experiment sent versions of one fictitious mother's application to 9,022 employers. With a gap of two and a half years, “Left to become a full-time mother and look after my children” got the same callbacks as the gap left unexplained.3
A US audit sent 3,407 applications for professional jobs in 50 cities, each from a parent with an 18-month gap or none. “Left to take care of my children” got interview requests 4.9% of the time for mothers and 5.4% for fathers. “Laid off due to downsizing” got 9.7% and 8.8%, and no gap about 15%. The study had no unexplained gap to compare, so it can't say whether leaving the reason off would have done better.4
Health reasons went both ways. In a US audit, “I had a medical issue. It is now taken care of” did a little better than no explanation.5 In Belgium, naming depression did no better or worse than saying nothing.6 In Norway, a year out for “mental health challenges” drew interview invitations 20.7% of the time, against 28.5% for a year of travel.7
Our take: a few true words do the job. If the reason is health, “Career break” is true and enough. If you’d rather say more, and it’s behind you, say it’s resolved. Spend the rest of the space on the work you did before the break and since.
Leave off a stopgap job far below your level
In one US experiment, a recent job well below the applicant's skill level drew about as few callbacks as a year out of work. Our advice: list a course, a project, or freelance work in your field, and leave off work that reads like a step down. An application that asks for every job still gets the full list.
Limitations
- These are audit studies: fictitious applications, measured by callbacks, not hires.
- The UK caregiving test used one mother and one wording. The US test had no unexplained gap to compare.
- We found no study of what to say about a break in an interview, or of “sabbatical,” travel, or a gap year as labels. Those parts are our take.
- No study has tested whether a referral makes up for a gap. The contacts study followed workers laid off when their plants closed, not people returning from a break.
- The studies span the UK, the US, Belgium, Norway, and Italy, and different kinds of jobs.